Reply to "Comment on 'Synthesis and properties of selenium trihydride at high pressures'"
文献类型:期刊论文
作者 | Zhang, Xiao5,6; Xu, Wan5,6; Wang, Yu5,6![]() |
刊名 | PHYSICAL REVIEW B
![]() |
出版日期 | 2018-09-11 |
卷号 | 98期号:10页码:2 |
ISSN号 | 2469-9950 |
DOI | 10.1103/PhysRevB.98.106102 |
通讯作者 | Zhang, Xiao() |
英文摘要 | The Comment of Pace et al. [Phys. Rev. B 98, 106101 (2018)] claims that structural analysis and nomenclature of Zhang et al. [Zhang, Xu, Wang, Jiang, Gorelli, Greenberg, Prakapenka, and Goncharov, Phys. Rev. B 97, 064107 (2018)] are incorrect, that this compound is not metallic at high pressures and 200 K, and that the compound instead decomposes. In this Reply we argue that there are no experimental data that can discriminate between theoretically predicted Cccm H3Se and I4/mcm (H2Se)(2)H-2 advocated by Pace et al. The difference in nomenclature is due to different naming conventions. We find the name "H3Se" more convenient to apply in the limit of high pressure. We also substantiate the initial claims of the stability up to 40 GPa at 170 K of the H3Se compound after synthesis at 4.6 GPa and argue that the pressure induced metallization above 23 GPa is a plausible explanation of the reported visual observations and Raman spectroscopy results. |
资助项目 | National Natural Science Foundation of China[21473211] ; National Natural Science Foundation of China[11674330] ; National Natural Science Foundation of China[11604342] ; National Natural Science Foundation of China[11504382] ; National Natural Science Foundation of China[51727806] ; Science Challenge Project[TZ2016001] ; Chinese Academy of Sciences[2011T2J20] ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; US NSF[EAR-1128799] ; US NSF[DMR-1231586] ; DOE Geosciences[DE-FG02-94ER14466] ; DOE-BES[DEAC02-06CH11357] |
WOS研究方向 | Physics |
语种 | 英语 |
WOS记录号 | WOS:000444347600004 |
出版者 | AMER PHYSICAL SOC |
资助机构 | National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; National Natural Science Foundation of China ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Science Challenge Project ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Chinese Academy of Sciences ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; Recruitment Program of Foreign Experts ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; US NSF ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE Geosciences ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES ; DOE-BES |
源URL | [http://ir.hfcas.ac.cn:8080/handle/334002/38755] ![]() |
专题 | 合肥物质科学研究院_中科院固体物理研究所 |
通讯作者 | Zhang, Xiao |
作者单位 | 1.European Lab Non Linear Spect LENS, I-50019 Sesto Fiorentino, Italy 2.CNR, INO, I-50019 Sesto Fiorentino, Italy 3.Carnegie Inst Sci, Geophys Lab, Washington, DC 20015 USA 4.Univ Chicago, Ctr Adv Radiat Sources, Chicago, IL 60637 USA 5.Chinese Acad Sci, Inst Solid State Phys, Key Lab Mat Phys, Hefei 230031, Anhui, Peoples R China 6.Univ Sci & Technol China, Hefei 230026, Anhui, Peoples R China |
推荐引用方式 GB/T 7714 | Zhang, Xiao,Xu, Wan,Wang, Yu,et al. Reply to "Comment on 'Synthesis and properties of selenium trihydride at high pressures'"[J]. PHYSICAL REVIEW B,2018,98(10):2. |
APA | Zhang, Xiao.,Xu, Wan.,Wang, Yu.,Jiang, Shuqing.,Gorelli, Federico A..,...&Goncharov, Alexander F..(2018).Reply to "Comment on 'Synthesis and properties of selenium trihydride at high pressures'".PHYSICAL REVIEW B,98(10),2. |
MLA | Zhang, Xiao,et al."Reply to "Comment on 'Synthesis and properties of selenium trihydride at high pressures'"".PHYSICAL REVIEW B 98.10(2018):2. |
入库方式: OAI收割
来源:合肥物质科学研究院
浏览0
下载0
收藏0
其他版本
除非特别说明,本系统中所有内容都受版权保护,并保留所有权利。