Clay minerals are ubiquitous in subsurface environments and have long been recognized as having a limited or negligible impact on the fate of arsenic (As) due to their negatively charged surfaces. Here, we demonstrate the significant role of kaolinite (Kln), a pervasive clay mineral, in enhancing As(V) immobilization during ferrous iron (Fe(II)) oxidation at near-neutral pH. Our results showed that Fe(II) oxidation alone was not capable of immobilizing As(V) at relatively low Fe/As molar ratios (≤2) due to the generation of Fe(III)–As(V) nanocolloids that could still migrate easily as truly dissolved As did. In the presence of kaolinite, dissolved As(V) was significantly immobilized on the kaolinite surfaces via forming Kln–Fe(III)–As(V) ternary precipitates, which had large sizes (at micrometer levels) to reduce the As mobility. The kaolinite-induced heterogeneous pathways for As(V) immobilization involved Fe(II) adsorption, heterogeneous oxidation of adsorbed Fe(II), and finally heterogeneous nucleation/precipitation of Fe(III)–As(V) phases on the edge surfaces of kaolinite. The surface precipitates were mixtures of amorphous basic Fe(III)–arsenate and As-rich hydrous ferric oxide. Our findings provide new insights into the role of clay minerals in As transformation, which is significant for the fate of As in natural and engineered systems.